Provincial golf course irrigation program sought
Posted by: Len Taylor in Legislature News, UncategorizedHon. Nancy Heppner
Minister of the Environment
Room 315
Legislative Building
Regina, Saskatchewan
S4S 0B3
Dear Minister:
I am writing with a suggestion for the Ministry’s budget development consideration for the provincial budget in 2010. The proposal will result in a reduction of and a more efficient use of water, less chemical use, and reduced energy consumption.
The idea stems from fundraising being done in The Battlefords for a new irrigation system for the municipal golf course. I am enclosing some newspaper clippings to support my argument and to outline the situation facing residents of The Battlefords. Of course, most other municipal and regional courses in the province are in the same situation.
The membership operates the North Battleford Golf Club, a municipal course that receives some capital contributions from the City most years. The 20 and 30 year old irrigation system needs replacing at a significant cost. There are currently no funding programs that specifically allow the management of the golf course to seek capital or infrastructure financial support from the province. I acknowledge that there are municipal infrastructure support programs, however in this and most other cases the municipality is unlikely to apply for matching funding because of other municipal priorities, which include roads and bridges, sewer and water systems, and regional use recreation facilities.
Most municipal golf courses in Saskatchewan are about the same age. Their irrigation systems are also about the same age and many are beginning to deteriorate. Most courses will begin to replace aging irrigation infrastructure in the near future.
The North Battleford golf course and I would argue others in the province have specific infrastructure needs as they endeavor to become more “green”, more environmentally friendly. In the case of North Battleford, the old and existing irrigation system is wasting
water. It wastes water by irrigating for lengthy periods of time sections of the course that require much less watering time, and it wastes water because of numerous line breaks throughout the months of the golf season. It is also wasting energy powering parts of the irrigation system that don’t need to be on all the time.
Engineers have provided great advice to the Board of Directors at the golf course on new systems, and the one chosen in North Battleford will reduce the wastage of significant amounts of water every year.
The engineers inform me that during dry periods of time the course is watered for seven to eight hours each night and uses approximately 340,000 US gallons of water to irrigate 59 acres of turf. If the existing irrigation system, as they suggest, applies water at a rate of 50% efficiency to the root zone of the plant, then the existing system wastes 170,000 US gallons of water each day. A new system is expected to get closer to 90 percent efficiency in applying water where it needs to be placed.
That is just in North Battleford. There are, according to the Saskatchewan Golf Association, 12 municipal courses in Saskatchewan. When all irrigation systems are replaced this means that (170,000 X 12) 2,040,000 US gallons of water per day would not be wasted. Further, with a five month (150 day) golf season, if we calculate that half of those days are “dry days”, then more efficient irrigation systems province wide on municipal golf course would eliminate the wastage of roughly 561 million US gallons of water during the season, more if the season is unusually dry.
There are also 32 regional golf courses in the province, which allow easy public access, that would benefit from funding for new irrigation systems, and would contribute even more to the more efficient use of water throughout the province.
The engineers also tell me that in North Battleford a new more efficient irrigation system would use about 20% less power to pump water from the river to the holding system, and then onto the course. Given that the course purchases about $10,000 in electricity to power their irrigation pumps, the savings in the case of North Battleford is about $2,000 per year. On a provincial basis, over time, this savings in energy use is again significant.
I don’t think I have to remind you that irrigation for agricultural use in Saskatchewan is substantial. When river water is pumped to the crop, it is either consumed or evaporates. Very little finds its way back to the river. To be most effective the water must go to the roots and be brought up through the leaves. This is exactly what happens on a golf course. If too much water is applied, that water can damage the plant root systems, wash away soil, or wash away adjacent ecosystems. Being able to reduce intensity improves efficiency, and reduces costs. Any changes in the way we irrigate will make a big difference in a lot of different ways for the future, and golf course managers are leading the way in this work.
And, lets not forget that although it is harder to quantify, but if water is getting to where it needs to go, and only at times which are necessary, then the need to apply chemical to the course would change as would the way in which that chemical is applied, improving the green footprint of the course. Chemical application doesn’t work as well when there is either too much or too little water on the specified areas.
In 2010 the irrigation system will be replaced in North Battleford with the newer, more environmentally friendly system. And, the municipality has already stepped up to the plate. The cost of the new system will be $1.5 million with the City of North Battleford paying for half of this and the golf course itself must fundraise for the other half. This is a significant undertaking but it is one that the membership is embracing because they believe in their golf course, and they realize that this course is recognized throughout western Canada as a prime regional facility, attracting people from Alberta, British Columbia, and Manitoba on a regular basis to the community. If this, and other courses in the province, fail to irrigate effectively, the course loses its attraction to the tourist and they will find somewhere else to play.
I think there are many reasons why the province of Saskatchewan should contribute to a new irrigation system at this location however I am also aware that there is currently no provincial program that would allow the management of the golf course to make this request.
I am also aware that numerous significant and important golf courses throughout the province would also be interested in improving their infrastructure if provincial funding was available.
Therefore, I am writing to suggest (in aid of the North Battleford golf course and others like it around the province) that the Province of Saskatchewan develop a municipal and regional golf course water management infrastructure support program that recognizes changes that enhance environmentally friendly approaches to irrigation management as well as significant municipal contributions to the same goal. It could be a new program, or it could be integrated into existing provincial infrastructure support programs.
The new program would likely not require a great deal of funding, however it would send a message that the province of Saskatchewan values the work done by individual golf courses to improve their environmental footprint by using less water, less chemical, and less energy, as well as encourage a sport that has become a significant tourism draw in rural Saskatchewan. I expect that North Battleford, for example, would find a one-third contribution, or $500,000 toward this goal to be an appropriate provincial contribution.
At a time when golf is a growing sport among young people, and represents a significant portion of tourism dollars in rural Saskatchewan, the courses in Saskatchewan continue to offer affordable and accessible play for all people in the community. In the case of the North Battleford course, 37% of the membership are seniors, and almost 10% are juniors.
I close by saying that using a lot less water, energy, and chemicals is all good public policy and more importantly is good for all people. The proposal warrants some consideration.
Your consideration is most appreciated.
Yours sincerely,
Len Taylor, MLA
The Battlefords
Entries (RSS)